Maple leaves and motherhood

From my corner on the sofa, I watch the red maple leaves waft to the front yard outside the living room window. This year, I find the seasonal herald to winter comforting. Brisk tromps in the snow will follow the leaves. Cozy months will pass inside. Now I can look ahead.

I look down at Owen, my drowsy, nursing, one-year-old son. We’ve spent

To everything there is a season

An equinox birth throws life off-balance.

hours on this sofa corner since his birth last September. From his vantage point, the view is always the same. From mine, with the view out the window, it’s been relentless change.

In the first weeks of his life I watched the maple leaves turn from green to yellow to orange-red. They floated to the ground, leaving stark branches against a cold, gray sky.  I imagined the tree might feel as helpless as I felt as a new mother, powerless to stop its once lush, full canopy from withering and dying.

Inside, I wanted to turn back to our days as a couple, before my husband and I ever conceived the notion of parenthood, let alone a baby. Our son’s care was a chronic round of unrewarding drudgery: Feed, sleep, wake, change, soothe, repeat. After his first week at home, any maternal joy was smothered by anxiety, exhaustion and resentment. Life as I’d known it had withered. The birth that had come, ironically, with the autumnal equinox had thrown me completely off balance. 

Late fall can be cruel, watching the trees’ blazing coats become tatters, knowing that inevitably, all must succumb to the wind, wet and winter. Last fall, it was colic that snuffed out the color in our lives. The crying was worst in late afternoon, coinciding with my husband’s return from work. I became a clock-watcher, willing those wails to wait until Mike at least had got in the door. I usually lost. We played pass-the-baby for four hours, until exhaustion finally led to sleep. Minutes later, we too were in bed, clutching each other for comfort, emotionally as bruised as the mottled gray sky. Oh, how I wanted those trees leafy and green again, as they were during my pregnancy, when we imagined only the fulfillment of becoming a family.

November. First snowfall. Wet, heavy snow, the kind that falls around 30 degrees and melts in two days. It plastered the naked maple branches. One 2 a.m. feeding, a sharp crack pierced my drowsy stupor. I got up from our sofa corner and peered out at the dark back yard. A huge branch had cracked off the old white pine, the heavy wet snow too much for it to bear. Frosty needles wiped the glass of the sliding door as it rested on the patio.

Later I would notice how crazily that branch had grown from the pine’s trunk, jutting out at an unsustainable angle. It was no surprise it yielded to the pressure of the snow, but I never considered it might fall. Nor did I see the metaphor it made to events on my side of the sliding door.

Some time before Christmas. I took Owen to run errands. Snow that was staying covered the streets. An opaque, dirty white sky blurred into the earth at the horizon, giving me the sense of occupying a fishbowl. I parked on the bridge over the river. We ran our errand, then returned to the car, me pushing his stroller through the sidewalk slush. From the corner of my eye I noticed the cold, frothing river. The car seat is heavy. Owen is strapped in. I could just drop this in, and it would all be over.

The thought wandered through my mind. I felt detached from it, like my mind was a marquee and this was today’s message. I felt no urge to act, to actually dangle the car seat over the bridge and release my grasp. I was merely a bystander to the emotions playing in my head. That was the scariest part: Not that such a thought could percolate up from the trough of my postpartum mind, but that I reacted so numbly, as if it were unremarkable. I snapped the seat in the car, shut the door and drove home inside the dirty white fishbowl that was my world.

Winter deepened. We approached the three-month mark. This was the crossroads. Even the few parents who would confide that they, too, had struggled with infancy assured us Things Would Get Better at three months. Instead of feeling like fumbling novices, rushing to our library of parenting books with every question, we would be competent, confident, instinctive parents. We could decode crying, soothe and comfort on demand. Another seasonal coincidence held tantalizing promise. The three-month mark fell on Christmas. If true, it would be the best Christmas present ever. It was also just days after the winter solstice, the return of the light. After living in a world shadowed by tormenting regrets and wishful thinking for three months, I willed for light again.

But those other parents were wrong. Things did not get better. Instead they deteriorated with every January day. My snowbird mother-in-law returned from her Florida home to lend a hand. From my corner on the living room sofa, the world looked cold and bleak. We’d dragged the broken pine branch off the patio into the backyard. Snow would cover it, then melt, exposing broken, dead, ugly branches. As a mother I felt broken, dead and ugly, too. “I want to like it more,” I told my husband one night. Talk about the awful truth. Owen was crying less. He was sleeping more. He smiled sometimes. But though I loved him, I did not like being a mother. Like the pine branch that cracked under the wet snow, I too broke down. I called a counselor and made an appointment.

I never thought I would welcome February. In February, winter becomes wearying. February teases with its thaws and lengthening daylight, yet the knowledge that winter’s grip won’t relent for at least another month. Last February, though, life finally relented. On the recommendation of my counselor, we arranged part-time child care. Owen’s sleeping improved. He started eating food in addition to nursing, relieving the pressure I carried to be his sole source of sustenance.

But it was the child care that was balm for my wracked psyche. These were golden hours, 16 of them each week that nurtured my starved soul. Time to work, to write, to feel competent at something. I started to anticipate the days again. Knowing respite was available, I unexpectedly began to enjoy my hours with Owen.

Spring beckoned. From the sofa corner, watching the maple tree begin to bud out in the front yard, I realized our kinship. All living things need time to replenish. Fertility and dormancy are a necessary cycle. As mother and son, our relationship started to truly flourish as the buds unfurled into the first of the green, green maple leaves. In the backyard a rhododendron, formerly shaded by the fallen pine branch, bloomed this spring for the first time, a gorgeous deep fuchsia.

Like the rest of the landscape, Owen and I ripened together in the warmth of summer. Mother is still the most draining, demanding role I’ve ever attempted to fulfill. But this fall, as I sit with Owen on the sofa corner, watching the maple leaves once again flutter to the ground, I feel no longing to return them to the tree.

* * * *

Dear readers – this essay was written upon my son’s first birthday in September 2006. (That’s him below, blowing out the candles at his fourth

Four years ago, I couldn't have envisioned a birthday celebration

Four years ago, I couldn't have envisioned a birthday celebration

fete last weekend.) My hope in publishing it now is that it will help balance the fairytale so many women are led to believe about motherhood. Unrealistic expectations and the feeling that I was alone in disliking and regretting this life-changing role worsened new motherhood for me.

I’ve recovered fully, and even had a second child, now one year old. With my expectations of motherhood more realistic, I did not experience post-partum depression with her. I hope that also helps women for whom PPD is a real and present threat to their well-being and that of their family. So please forward and link to this post. I’m glad to join This Mommy Gig — and I promise to be shorter in the future.

5 Comments so far

  1. Wow. So beautiful. I’d like to come up with something smart and witty and apropos to say - but that would only tarnish the perfectly chosen and crafted words that you just shared with us. There’s literally nothing left to say. Thank you…and incredibly glad you’re here.

  2. Beautifully written piece. As a writer and as the mother of triplets (now 15 years old) I can well remember the freedom that childcare provided.

  3. As I told Cari in email, I love the imagery of the maple tree as a helpless pawn in nature’s larger play, which is not unlike what happens to all of us when we become parents. Our bodies are not our own… and increasingly, our thoughts, our minds, our emotions, and our hearts become hijacked by something larger than ourselves. This isn’t entirely a bad thing, and I’ve come to see it as an essential part of motherhood. And maturity. And all that. At 17 and 12, my kids are long past the nursing years, yet I feel it anew at every stage still. Most recently, when my oldest went to the Rhode Island School of Design for the summer:

    At A Loss for Words
    http://www.annhandley.com/2009/06/27/at-a-loss-for-words/

    That said, I have never suffered PPD like you have, Cari. But I still recall those first few years when I was home full-time with my children as some of the more difficult and loneliest of my life. I was unprepared for how brutal the transition was, and I couldn’t help but feel, when I was spending my days with new baby and then, eventually, a toddler and his baby brother, “What’s wrong with me? Why aren’t I totally fulfilled by this?” The stay-at-home Mom bit was entirely of my choosing, and I don’t know that I could have tolerated any other way, but still. It wasn’t an easy time.

    I am honored to have you here, Cari. Looking forward to more of your stories, going forward.

  4. Thanks for the welcome and warm comments, everyone. Julie, it was one of your posts (Cuff me and haul me away) that was up when I stumbled upon Mommy Gig a month or so ago. I read it and thought, “THERE is someone who is on my parenting wavelength.” Glad to be among thinking mothers (and dads) and looking forward to reading more from all.
    Cari

  5. Cari - Beautifully-written essay. Thank you for sharing, for being so honest about your experience. I, too, went through much of what you’ve described here, after my first child was born and, to a greater extent, after my third. Not sure what was different exactly after my second joined us, but his early months were decidely more enjoyable…maybe it was the nearly 4-year span between the second and third that contributed to my second downward spiral. I’d finally gotten through those early baby years with two and BAM - I had a newborn again!

    I like how you share the photo of Owen at his 4th birthday with this post. Time does carry on, seasons do change and life does somehow get…easier? I don’t believe that’s the right word exactly, since it’s never really easier. Different challenges crop up and all that. But with my kids now ages 9, 7 and 4, I’m sometimes a tiny bit nostalgic about the days of nursing and stroller walks and gummy smiles. But really, only a little! Mostly, I am relishing these days of taking family trips without diaper bags and watching my kids’ talents for sports or writing or whatever it may be unfold before my eyes. It’s just awesome, and really what I looked forward to when I pictured myself a mom all those years ago.

    I look forward to reading more of your posts here - and those of others. This is a great site!

    Great job, Cari…I’m going to share this with others.

    Heather

Leave a Reply


Comment: